Home » UPC decisions » Local Division » Mannheim Local Division » LD Mannheim, January 13, 2026, Order, UPC_CFI_850/2026

LD Mannheim, January 13, 2026, Order, UPC_CFI_850/2026

4 min Reading time

Key takeaways

✓

The decision on rejecting the claimant’s allegedly late FRAND submissions, and final admission of the defendant’s reply, is deferred to the panel after the oral hearing.

✓

The court closed the written phase and refused an extension; the defendant may file a narrowly scoped, provisional reply on the specific FRAND point. Case management supports avoiding delay (Art. 43 UPCA).

✓
  • Confidentiality applies to the licence and derived non-public information; access limited to registered UPC representatives (and their assistants), three client employees, and an external economic expert team.
  • Strict use limitations apply; enforceability relies on the UPC representatives’ Rules of Conduct and sanction regime (Rules 290.2, 291 RoP).
✓
  • At its own request, the defendant is ordered to produce the third‑party licence by a set date, subject to a right to withdraw the request by that deadline.
  • The court found the Rule 262A confidentiality regime sufficient to protect licensee interests and enable fair rebuttal on the specific FRAND point.
✓

Abstract FRAND issues remain public; any exclusion at hearing or in the decision is limited to specific confidential information protected under the order.

✓

Confidential information may only be used in these proceedings; obligations continue post‑termination. Culpable breaches may trigger periodic penalty payments; the new order supersedes the preliminary order.

Division

LD Mannheim

UPC number

UPC_CFI_850/2024

Type of proceedings

Main infringement proceedings (FRAND issues, interim procedural orders)

Parties

Claimant: ZTE Corporation

Defendants/Applicants: Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd.; Samsung Electronics GmbH; Samsung Electronics France; Samsung Electronics Italia S.p.A; Samsung Electronics Benelux B.V.; Samsung Electronics Romania S.R.L.

Patent(s)

EP 3 905 730

Jurisdictions

UPC

Body of legislation / Rules

R. 36 RoP, R. 262A RoP


Was the article helpful?


Categories


Tags

Stay in the loop

Never miss a beat by subscribing to the email newsletter. Please see our Privacy Policy.

* = Required field