Home » UPC decisions » Central Division » Munich Central Division » CD Munich, 27 February 2024, order to combine cases in revocation actions, UPC_CFI_1/2023, UPC_CFI_14/2023

CD Munich, 27 February 2024, order to combine cases in revocation actions, UPC_CFI_1/2023, UPC_CFI_14/2023

3 min Reading time

Key takeaways

The parties agreed that the counterclaim for revocation pending at LD Munich should be dealt with together with an earlier filed and considerably further advanced central revocation action pending at the CD. The LD Munich thus referred the counterclaim to the CD. The CD (Section Munich) ordered that both actions are dealt with jointly under the conditions that all parties are “on the same page” where it concerns the grounds for revocation, arguments, facts and evidence, such that both cases can be dealt with together in the foreseen timeline for the revocation action. The parties and the judge rapporteur agreed that it was “deemed” that all facts, grounds, arguments etc. are known to all parties and that those having been submitted in the recovation action have also been submitted in the counterclaim for revocation and vice versa.

(Only) costs may be dealt with separately.

In order to assess whether the costs incurred can be recovered which requires that they are “reasonable and proportionate”, Art. 69 UPCA, the Court and parties must have access to information showing at least a detailed description of the number of hours spent working on this particular case, by whom, what for and at what rate.

The Court will, in principle, respect an agreement between the parties on the amount of costs that is deemed reasonable and proportionate.


Panel 1 of the Central Division (Section Munich)

UPC number

UPC_CFI_1/2023, UPC_CFI_14/2023

Type of proceedings

Revocation action


1st Claimants: Sanofi-Aventis Deutschland GmbH, Sanofi-Aventis Groupe, Sanofi Winthrop Industrie S.A.,

2nd Claimant: Regeneron Pharmaceuticals Inc.

Defendant: Amgen, Inc.



Body of legislation/Rules

Art. 69 UPCA, Rule 9 RoP, Rule 103 RoP

Was the article helpful?



  • Alexander Wunsch

    German and European Patent Attorney, UPC Representative, Counsel

  • Anna Giedke

    Attorney-at-Law (Rechtsanwältin), UPC Representative, Partner

Stay in the loop

Never miss a beat by subscribing to the email newsletter. Please see our Privacy Policy.

* = Required field